What am I looking at?

What you are looking at

Each point is how fast a real galaxy turns at one distance from its centre, measured from the light of its hydrogen gas. The lines under the points are what the gravity of its stars and gas alone would give: far out they fall short. Add a dark matter halo, fit it, and read how much unseen mass the galaxy needs. The second tab puts every point of 153 galaxies on one plot: the radial acceleration relation.

Controls

On this device:

Mouse

  • Pick a galaxy from the list, or click one of the Try buttons: NGC 3198, NGC 2403, DDO 154, F568-3, NGC 7814.
  • Click No halo, NFW or Pseudo-isothermal to choose the halo.
  • Drag the sliders: the stars' mass-to-light ratio Υ, then the halo's two numbers (V₂₀₀ and c, or ρ₀ and r_c).
  • Click Fit to let the model find the best halo, Υ, distance and inclination together; Start over goes back to the catalogue values.
  • Click Every galaxy for the radial acceleration relation; drag its Υ slider and click 1 or 2 to read what dark matter and MOND say.
  • Click the badge under the galaxy's facts for the data's source and citation.

Keyboard

  • Tab to the galaxy list; the arrow keys pick a galaxy.
  • Tab to a slider; the arrow keys move it, Home and End jump to its ends.
  • Tab to a button (Try, the halo, Fit, Start over, the readings); Enter or Space presses it.
  • On the tabs, the left and right arrows switch between Rotation curve and Every galaxy.
  • With a screen reader, each plot reads out the galaxy, the last radius and the speeds there.
  • H or ? opens this panel. Esc closes it.
Other devices

Touch

  • Tap the galaxy list to pick one of 163, or tap a Try button.
  • Tap No halo, NFW or Pseudo-isothermal to choose the halo.
  • Slide Υ and the halo's two sliders with your finger.
  • Tap Fit for the best model, Start over for the catalogue values.
  • Tap Every galaxy for the whole sample on one plot, then 1 or 2 for the two readings.
  • Tap the source badge for where the data come from.

Glossary

Rotation curve
How fast stars and gas circle a galaxy's centre at each radius. In a disk galaxy it rises quickly and then stays about flat, far past where the light fades.
Why it matters If the visible mass were all, the speed would fall off far out, as the planets' speeds do round the Sun.
SPARC
Spitzer Photometry and Accurate Rotation Curves: 175 disk galaxies with infrared photometry from the Spitzer space telescope and rotation curves from radio and optical data (Lelli, McGaugh and Schombert 2016). The module uses the 163 with quality 1 or 2.
Why it matters One homogeneous sample, so every galaxy is modelled the same way.
Measured speed, with error bars
The rotation speed at each radius, from the Doppler shift of hydrogen's 21 cm radio line and of Hα light, corrected for the disk's tilt. The bar is its measured uncertainty.
Radius (kpc)
Distance from the galaxy's centre in kiloparsecs. One kiloparsec is about 3260 light-years; the Sun sits about 8 kpc from the centre of the Milky Way.
Stars and gas (baryons)
The ordinary matter we can see. The stars line comes from the 3.6 µm infrared light of the disk and bulge; the gas line from the atomic hydrogen measured, with helium added. Stars and gas together is V_bar² = V_gas|V_gas| + Υ_d V_disk² + Υ_b V_bul².
Why it matters Its gap below the points is what a halo has to fill.
Mass-to-light ratio Υ
How many solar masses of stars each solar luminosity of 3.6 µm light stands for. Stellar population models give about 0.5 for disks and 0.7 for bulges; the fit lets it move with a prior of 0.1 dex round those values.
Why it matters Heavier stars could fill some of the gap, but not as far out as the points go.
Dark matter halo
A roughly round cloud of matter that gives off no light, larger than the visible galaxy. The model adds its speed to the baryons': V² = V_bar² + V_halo².
NFW halo (V₂₀₀, c)
The density profile cold dark matter simulations give (Navarro, Frenk and White 1996), steep to the centre. V₂₀₀ is the speed at r₂₀₀, where the halo's mean density is 200 times the universe's critical density; the concentration c says how much of its mass sits near the middle.
Why it matters It is what the standard cosmology predicts, so how well it fits is a test.
Pseudo-isothermal halo (ρ₀, r_c)
A halo with a flat-density core of radius r_c and central density ρ₀, falling as 1/r² outside. It is an empirical shape, not a prediction.
Why it matters Dwarfs such as DDO 154 often fit a core better than the NFW cusp: the cusp-core problem.
Fit
Least squares (Levenberg–Marquardt): the halo's two numbers, Υ, distance and inclination move together until the model passes as close to the points as their error bars allow. Distance and inclination may move within the catalogue's errors, as Li et al. 2020 let them.
χ²/ν (reduced chi-squared)
The sum of each point's miss squared, in units of its error bar, divided by the number of points minus the numbers the fit sets. Near 1 is a good fit; far above 1 the model misses.
Why it matters It turns 'does the line go through the points' into one number.
Halo mass inside the last point
How much dark matter the model puts inside the last measured radius: V_halo² r / G, in solar masses (M☉).
Dark share
Of all the mass inside the last measured radius, the share the halo provides. In most galaxies it is well over half.
Why it matters It says how much of the galaxy is matter no telescope has seen.
Distance and inclination used
The galaxy's distance sets its size and the stars' mass; its tilt converts the speed seen along the line of sight into the true one. The catalogue gives each with an error; the fit may move them within it.
Radial acceleration relation
At every measured radius of every galaxy, the acceleration the rotation shows, g_obs = V²/r, against what stars and gas give by Newton, g_bar = V_bar²/r. All 153 galaxies fall on one curve (McGaugh, Lelli and Schombert 2016).
Why it matters One curve for galaxies of every size is a strong clue to how dark matter, or gravity, behaves.
g† (acceleration scale)
The acceleration where the relation bends away from g_obs = g_bar, about 1.2 × 10⁻¹⁰ m/s²: a hundred-billionth of the Earth's gravity. The module fits it to the sample as you change Υ.
Scatter (dex)
How far the points sit from the fitted curve, on average, in powers of ten: 0.13 dex is about 35%.
MOND
Modified Newtonian Dynamics (Milgrom 1983): instead of unseen mass, gravity itself grows stronger than Newton's below an acceleration a₀ about equal to g†.
Why it matters It predicts the relation from the visible mass alone, but struggles in galaxy clusters and with the cosmic microwave background.

All help and questions

163 SPARC galaxies
Distance
13.80 ± 1.40 Mpc
Inclination
73 ± 3°
Type
Sc
Quality
1, high
Radii measured
43
050100150010203040Radius (kpc)Rotation speed (km/s)
  • Measured, with error bars
  • Gas
  • Stars
  • Stars and gas
  • Model: all together

At 44 kpc the stars and gas give 65 km/s; the galaxy turns at 149 km/s.

Solar masses per solar luminosity at 3.6 µm. Stellar populations suggest about 0.5.

No halo: the best stars and gas alone can do. Pick NFW or pseudo-isothermal and press Fit.

Fit quality χ²/ν
816
Halo mass inside 44 kpc
none
Dark share at 44 kpc
0%
Distance used
13.80 Mpc
Inclination used
73.0°

What you are looking at

Each point is how fast gas and stars circle this galaxy's centre at one radius, measured from the Doppler shift of hydrogen's 21 cm line and of Hα light. The lines under it are what Newton's gravity of the visible mass alone would give: the stars, from their 3.6 µm light times a mass-to-light ratio Υ, and the gas, from the hydrogen seen. Far out they fall short. Add a halo of unseen mass and fit it.

Reading the fit

χ²/ν near 1 means the model passes through the points about as closely as their error bars allow; far above 1 it misses. NFW is the halo cold dark matter simulations make, dense to the very centre; the pseudo-isothermal sphere has a flat core. Many dwarfs, such as DDO 154, prefer the core: the cusp-core problem.

Data

Rotation curves and mass models: SPARC, F. Lelli, S. McGaugh and J. Schombert, AJ 152, 157 (2016), 10.3847/0004-6256/152/6/157, quality 1 and 2. SPARC states no licence and asks users to cite that paper. The fit follows P. Li, F. Lelli, S. McGaugh and J. Schombert, ApJS 247, 31 (2020).